4 Stars
See prices from 22 sites
from£129
See prices from 22 sites
from£129
  • Bedroom
  • Bathroom

1 / 99

About Amara Cay Resort

  • On-site fishing from dock

    Fish directly from the resort dock, with catch-and-release fishing available for guests using their own or rented gear.

  • Heated pool and Tiki Bar

    Relax at the zero-entry heated outdoor pool or order lunch and cocktails from the poolside Tiki Bar.

  • Sea wall instead of beach

    The property features a sea wall with ladder access to the water rather than a traditional sandy beach.

  • Walkable dining at Lazy Days

    Walk just 200 yards south to dine at the popular Lazy Days Restaurant for fresh local seafood.

  • Access to three sister resorts

    Utilize the complimentary water taxi and shuttle service to visit and enjoy amenities at two nearby sister properties.

  • Potential room maintenance issues

    Some guest rooms have been reported to have musty odors, outdated decor, or malfunctioning air conditioning units.

Amara Cay Resort is a 4-star hotel in Islamorada, recognised with the 2015 Sandi Design award for Design Excellence Hospitality. The resort is beachfront, overlooking natural coral reefs, and offers a complimentary shuttle service for local attractions within 6 km. Guests can enjoy Italian and American dining at the ReelCatch restaurant, relax by the oceanfront pool with a tiki bar, or unwind on the private beach with hammocks. The hotel has a review score of 8.5 based on over 6,000 reviews, with public transit, location, and WiFi highlighted positively by guests.

This summary was created by AI and might not be 100% accurate.

Rooms

  • Matacumbe Courtyard View King

    • 1 1 King Bed and 1 Twin Sofa Bed
    • Sleeps 3
    • 378 sq ft
  • Alligator Reef Partial Ocean View 2 Queens

    • 1 2 Queen Beds
    • Sleeps 4
    • 345 sq ft
  • Matacumbe Accessible King with Lanai

    • 1 1 King Bed
    • Sleeps 2
    • 378 sq ft
  • Matacumbe Courtyard View King Lanai

    • 1 1 King Bed and 1 Twin Sofa Bed
    • Sleeps 3
    • 378 sq ft

Compare with similar stays

Selected stay

4 Stars

  • WiFi
  • Pool
  • Pets
See prices from 22 sites
from£129

Similar stays

  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • A/C
    See prices from 4 sites
    from£141
  • 4 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Parking
    See prices from 19 sites
    from£127
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Parking
    See prices from 10 sites
    from£161
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Parking
    See prices from 8 sites
    from£249
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Parking
    See prices from 12 sites
    from£246
  • 2 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Parking
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 4 Stars

    • Pool
    • Spa
    • Parking
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • A/C
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Parking
    Select dates to see exact prices

Price trend

Based on lowest prices on trivago from the last 30 days
£586
£295
£0

Sun, 22/11/26

£288

Mon, 23/11/26

£252

Tue, 24/11/26

£257

Wed, 25/11/26

£262

Thu, 26/11/26

£307

Fri, 27/11/26

£263

Sat, 28/11/26

£234

Sun, 29/11/26

£180

Mon, 30/11/26

£171

Tue, 01/12/26

£176

Wed, 02/12/26

£172

Thu, 03/12/26

£183

Fri, 04/12/26

£341

Sat, 05/12/26

£346

Sun, 06/12/26

£238

Mon, 07/12/26

£232

Tue, 08/12/26

£237

Wed, 09/12/26

£231

Thu, 10/12/26

£229

Fri, 11/12/26

£251

Sat, 12/12/26

N/A

Sun, 13/12/26

£199

Mon, 14/12/26

£205

Tue, 15/12/26

£269

Wed, 16/12/26

£267

Thu, 17/12/26

£274

Fri, 18/12/26

N/A

Sat, 19/12/26

N/A

Sun, 20/12/26

£286

Mon, 21/12/26

£281

Tue, 22/12/26

N/A

Wed, 23/12/26

£277

Thu, 24/12/26

£349

Fri, 25/12/26

N/A

Sat, 26/12/26

N/A

Sun, 27/12/26

£586

Mon, 28/12/26

N/A

Tue, 29/12/26

N/A

Wed, 30/12/26

N/A

Thu, 31/12/26

N/A

Fri, 01/01/27

N/A

Sat, 02/01/27

£416

Sun, 03/01/27

£266

Mon, 04/01/27

£257

Tue, 05/01/27

£276

Wed, 06/01/27

N/A

Thu, 07/01/27

£265

Fri, 08/01/27

£293

Sat, 09/01/27

N/A

Reviews

8.5
Excellent
based on 6,338 ratings from top 
sites
sites

Review summary

Summarized by AI from 1,000+ reviews

This resort is a vibrant, pet-friendly retreat ideal for families, couples, and sightseers seeking an engaging Florida Keys experience. The property boasts a prime location in Islamorada, offering easy walking access to local bars and restaurants. Its standout feature is the beautiful pool area and complimentary water sports equipment, including kayaks and paddleboards. Guests consistently praise the friendly and helpful staff, particularly the efficient front desk team and engaging shuttle drivers, and enjoy the quality food and diverse menu options, especially at the Tiki bar. For a unique and memorable activity, be sure to try the "Fish Like a Local" experience with Patrick.

Rated above average for Islamorada

Guest reviews

Excellent62%
Very good17%
Good10%
Fair5%
Poor6%

Top amenities

  • WiFi
  • Pool
  • Pets
  • A/C
  • Restaurant
  • Hotel bar
  • Gym

All amenities

Property amenities

  • Café
  • Entrance hall/lobby
  • Express check-in/check-out
  • Lift

For children

  • Cot
  • Kid meals

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Accessible travel path
  • Accessible parking

Room amenities

  • Ironing board
  • Openable windows
  • Television
  • Hairdryer

Sports facilities

  • Bike rental
  • Golf course
  • Fitness
  • Surfing

Hotel characteristics

  • Family friendly

Location

80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, 33036, USA

Highlight

Walkable dining at Lazy Days

Walk just 200 yards south to dine at the popular Lazy Days Restaurant for fresh local seafood.

Distance from Amara Cay Resort

  1. 0.6 miles from Island Adventures
  2. 2.6 miles from Islamorada Train Caboose
  3. 3 miles from History of Diving Museum
  4. 4.5 miles from Theater of the Sea
  5. 5.1 miles from Quarry Station
  6. 8.2 miles from Islamorada (City centre)
  7. 13.2 miles from The Laura Quinn Wild Bird Sanctuary
  8. 18.5 miles from Dolphins Plus
  9. 19.2 miles from African Queen
  10. 27.6 miles from Florida Keys Marathon International Airport
  11. 58.3 miles from Dadeland South

Explore nearby attractions

Property info

80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, 33036, USA

Frequently Asked Questions about Amara Cay Resort

Is there a pool area at Amara Cay Resort?

Yes, Amara Cay Resort offers 2 pool areas.

Are pets allowed at Amara Cay Resort?

Yes, Amara Cay Resort has a pet policy that may vary based on the room type or availability. Please check with the hotel directly to learn about their pet policy.

Is parking available at Amara Cay Resort?

Yes, Amara Cay Resort provides Accessible parking for guests.

What time is check-in and check-out at Amara Cay Resort?

Check-in at Amara Cay Resort is available from: . Check-out time is by .

Where is Amara Cay Resort located?

Amara Cay Resort is located in 80001 Overseas Hwy, 33036, Islamorada, USA.

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Among Top Rated Hotels in Islamorada

  • 4 Stars
    The Moorings Village & Spa
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars
    The Caribbean Resort
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars
    Flamingo Adventures Lodge
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars
    Caloosa Cove Resort by CoolVacay
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars
    Ocean House Resort
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • Windley Cottage At Anglers Way
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars
    Sunset Inn
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars
    Treasure Harbor
    See prices from 8 sites
    from£249

Destinations near Amara Cay Resort